A cross-validated discharge–grain-size model for maximum bed scour in a mobile-bed open channel
Keywords:
bed scour, mobile-bed channel, discharge, grain size, cross-validationAbstract
This study develops a compact empirical model for maximum bed scour in an unobstructed mobile-bed open channel. Experiments were conducted in a 9 m flume using a 3×3 matrix that combined discharges of 0.0026, 0.0034, and 0.0045 m³ s⁻¹ with nominal grain sizes of 2.36, 1.18, and 0.85 mm. Final bed change was measured at 20 sections and seven transverse points for each condition, providing 1,260 spatial observations. Maximum scour increased from 0.8 to 4.5 cm, while the proportion of scoured observation points rose from 19.3% to 100%. The additive relation dₛ(cm)=1.272+0.883Q*−1.037d* explained 93.5% of the fitted variance and retained R²=0.843 under leave-one-condition-out cross-validation, with RMSE=0.394 cm. A particle-densimetric-Froude formulation produced a very strong fit on the normalized response scale but only a marginal reduction in cross-validated error after back-transformation. Discharge and grain size therefore acted as comparably strong controls in opposite directions within the tested range. The proposed relation is intended for interpolation within this experimental domain rather than as a universal design equation.
Downloads
References
Abbasov R, Yahyayev V. The impact of dams and sand-gravel extractions on the downstream channel deformations (in the example of the Goychay River). Sustainable Water Resources Management. 2024;10(2).
Broner N, Laronne JB, Storz-Peretz Y. Influence of flood events on the response of steep and coarse-grained channels to base-level lowering in an arid setting. Journal of Hydrology. 2024;645.
Chang KH, Wu YT, Wang CH, Chang TJ. A new 2D ESPH bedload sediment transport model for rapidly varied flows over mobile beds. Journal of Hydrology. 2024;634.
Duan JG, Yu C, Ding Y. Numerical Simulation of Sediment Transport in Unsteady Open Channel Flow. Water (Switzerland). 2023;15(14).
Zerihun YT. Numerical Modeling of Sediment Transport and Bed Evolution in Nonuniform Open-Channel Flows. Archives of Hydroengineering and Environmental Mechanics. 2024;71(1):1-26.
Liu C, Fu S, Li Z, Zhang Z, Zeng J. Effects of sediment characteristics on the sediment transport capacity of overland flow. International Soil and Water Conservation Research. 2023;11(1):75-85.
Sen S, Hossain S, Ghoshal K. Distribution of non-uniform particles in an open channel flow from the concept of mixing length. Sedimentary Geology. 2022;440:106242.
Yao P, Su M, Wang Z, van Rijn LC, Stive MJF, Xu C, Chen Y. Erosion Behavior of Sand-Silt Mixtures: Revisiting the Erosion Threshold. Water Resources Research. 2022;58(9).
Qiao Z, Chen Y, Yao P, Su M, Stive M, Ren L, Wang Z. Suspension dynamics of sand-silt mixtures: Experimental insights and modelling implications. Journal of Hydrology. 2025;661.
Ikhsan C, Permana AS, Negara AS. Armor Layer Uniformity and Thickness in Stationary Conditions with Steady Uniform Flow. Civil Engineering Journal (Iran). 2022;8(6):1086-99.
de Menezes D, Borges ALO. Bed roughness in gravel-bed rivers: Channel-scale responses to flow and sediment dynamics. Advances in Water Resources. 2025;206.
Canelas OB, Ferreira RML, Cardoso AH. Hydro-Morphodynamics of an Open-Channel Confluence With Bed Discordance at Dynamic Equilibrium. Water Resources Research. 2022;58(1).
Aghazadegan A, Shokri A. Three-dimensional numerical simulation of mixing patterns at open channel confluences. Water Science and Engineering. 2025;18(2):236-46.
Behera PK, Deshpande V, Kumar B. Dynamics of turbulent flow over mobile dune. Flow. 2025;5.
Behera PK, Deshpande V, Kumar B. Morphodynamics of mobile dunes with downward seepage. Physics of Fluids. 2025;37(2).
Li J, Xu N, Wang H, Fu D, Liu X, Wu W. Experimental investigation of the interconnections between turbulent structure and scouring topographic characteristics. Frontiers in Environmental Engineering. 2023;2.
Malasani GC, Kantharaj M, Chandra V. Experimental study of suspended sediment transport at river confluence. Journal of Hydrology. 2026;671.
Devi G, Kumar M. Experimental study of the local scour around the two piers in the tandem arrangement using ultrasonic ranging transducers. Ocean Engineering. 2022;266:112838.
Alasadi LAR, Khlif TH, Hassan FA. Experimental investigation for the local scour around V-shaped spur-dikes. Scientific Review Engineering and Environmental Sciences. 2023;32(1).
Murtaza N, Khan ZU, Khedher KM, Amir RA, Khan D, Salem MA, Alsulamy S. Mitigating scour at bridge abutments: An experimental investigation of waste material as an eco-friendly solution. Water. 2023;15(21):3798.
Cely Calixto NJ, Galvis Castaño A, Carrillo Soto GA. Evaluation of Local Scour along the Base of Longitudinal Training Walls. Water (Switzerland). 2023;15(22).
Chibana T, Quiocho R, Watanabe K. Role of Grain Size Distribution and Pier Aspect Ratio in Scouring and Sorting around Bridge Piers. Water (Switzerland). 2022;14(13).
Chen F, Yang W, Liu F, Zhu L, Sun Z. Experimental Study of Sediment Incipient Velocity and Scouring in Submarine Cable Burial Areas. Water (Switzerland). 2025;17(9).
Baharuddin A, Karim N, Ali MY, Latif S. Investigasi eksperimental pengendalian gerusan pilar jembatan menggunakan deflektor arus bawah air berpori. Journal of Green Complex Engineering. 2026;3(2):83-94.
Nurizkitha IZ, Karim N, Al Imran H, Latif S. Efektivitas deflektor silinder pori bertulang dalam mengurangi kecepatan aliran di sekitar pilar jembatan. Journal of Green Complex Engineering. 2026;3(2):73-82.
Bhat NUH, Pahar G. Depth-averaged coupling of submerged granular deformation with fluid flow: An augmented HLL scheme. Journal of Hydrology. 2022;606.
Roushangar K, Ghasempour R, Azamathulla HM. An inverse problem for modeling open channel flow with movable bed. Water Supply. 2023;23(1):222-36.
Ahmed MA, Li SS. Efficient Data Assimilation Method for Optimizing Prediction of Flow Field and Sediment Transport in Open Channel. River Research and Applications. 2026;42(3):580-93.
Chen H, Wang F, Huai W, Li S. Analogues of Π Theorem via Machine Learning for Hydraulic Conveyance Laws. Water Resources Research. 2025;61(8).
Pandey M, Karbasi M, Jamei M, Malik A, Pu JH. A Comprehensive Experimental and Computational Investigation on Estimation of Scour Depth at Bridge Abutment: Emerging Ensemble Intelligent Systems. Water Resources Management. 2023;37(9):3745-67.
Guan D, Li Z, Zheng H, Hong JH, Fazeres-Ferradosa T, Asumadu R. Prediction of maximum scour depth downstream of bed sills using integrated machine learning algorithms. Environmental Modelling and Software. 2025;192.
Huang Y, Zhou X, Zhou W, Yao C, Zhou F. Numerical Analysis of Bed Shear Stress of a Rectangular Open Channel. Gongcheng Kexue Yu Jishu/Advanced Engineering Sciences. 2022;54(3):201-8.
Curulli G, Penna N, Gaudio R. Improved formulation for the geometric characteristics of the scour hole and deposition mound caused by a rotating propeller jet on a mobile bed. Ocean Engineering. 2023;267.
Yusuf M, Tongeng AB, Marupah M, Latif S. Analisis eksperimental pengaruh sabo dam tipe beam terhadap karakteristik aliran debris pada variasi kemiringan saluran. Journal of Green Complex Engineering. 2026;3(2):67-72.
Barahimi M, Sui J. Deformation of vegetated channel bed under ice-covered flow conditions. Journal of Hydrology. 2024;636.
Fleit G, Muste M, Baranya S, Kim D, Whaling A, McAlpin TO, You H. The acoustic-doppler current profiler (ADCP): A comprehensive tool for river hydromorphodynamics monitoring. Advances in Water Resources. 2025;206.
Good R, Nguyen D, Bonakdari H, Binns A, Gharabaghi B. Effect of Skewness Orientation on Morphological Adjustments in Alluvial Meandering Streams. Water (Switzerland). 2024;16(6).
Lee J, Marr J, Guala M. On Sediment Mass Flux Directionality Induced by Yawed Permeable Vanes under Near-Critical Mobility Conditions. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering. 2022;148(10).
Trevisson M, Eiff O. Fine-Sediment Erosion and Sediment-Ribbon Morphodynamics in Coarse-Grained Immobile Beds. Water Resources Research. 2022;58(11).
Hakim Safi W, Mohapatra PK. Effects of Bed Material and Downstream Flow Depth on the Evolution of Bed in a Right-Angled Open-Channel Confluence. Journal of Irrigation and Drainage Engineering. 2024;150(1).
Li J, Yang C, Chen X. Numerical investigation of grain size effect on velocity-skewed oscillatory sheet flow. Physics of Fluids. 2024;36(8).
Pandey A, Kantamaneni K, Behera PK, Deshpande V, Sarukkalige R, Rathnayake U. Linking Grain Size and Geospatial Indices: Sediment Transport Dynamics in the Ganga River at Varanasi, India. Earth (Switzerland). 2026;7(1).
Deng J, Brousse G, Jodeau M. How to improve numerical modelling of gravel replenishment with non-uniform sediment? Proof of concept with a comprehensive experimental dataset. Advances in Water Resources. 2025;206.
Ennazii AE, Beaudoin A, Ouchene R, Gomit G, Jarny S, Calluaud D. Study of Bed Erosion in an Open-Channel from Laboratory Measurements to Eulerian–Eulerian Two-Phase Modeling. Water (Switzerland). 2026;18(11).
Li K, Yu Q, Ma X, Wang L, Nie R. An Improved Physical Model for Open Channel Confluences: Bridging the Gap Between Laboratory and Field Observations. Water Resources Research. 2025;61(10).
Akmal A, Munawir M, Puteh MAF, Syauqi TM, Saputra H. Hydrological assessment of a water hyacinth (Eichhornia crassipes) filtration system for microplastic and water quality improvement in the Krueng Aceh River. Jurnal LINEARS. 2026;9(1):9-18.
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Copyright (c) 2026 Soemitro Emin Praja, Muhammad Nurhidayat, M. Agusalim, Asran
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms: (1) Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal; (2) Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal; (3) Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work.
Greenplex Research Journal of Green Complex Engineering is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
